I gave this a lot of thought and finally got it with the plan of, if I didn't like the look of it, taking the padded lid to an upholsterer and have them cover it with material that matches the seats.
But I just installed it and I think it probably looks fine. Regardless, it's an easy thing to remove - four screws and I can hand off the lid to someone and it shouldn't cost that much.
One thing that really is making me mad is that a few months ago when I got a passenger side armrest I took off that cap that covers the bolt where it attaches and put it SOMEWHERE. I can't find it anywhere.
I guess if I end up selling it (the armrest) I could make the cap part of the deal, since the buyer won't need it. But I'm irritated because I knew I set it aside somewhere and will probably find it in like ten years and wonder what the hell it is.
I will put a picture up soon of the Tuffy box. But it is really, really well made.
Here is the photo. It is misleading though, because the appearance of the different materials, visually, is much, much closer to eachother. But the Tuffy box and the FJ interior handle light very differently when photographed, evidently.
But I'm very happy with it. I still might get the top redone, but it's fine for now the way it is (and I'm picky!).
