Hey Sean,
I would rather keep my responses here in this thread because there are lots of folks who feel the same way you do and also lots of folks who follow your lead.
Really I think I made a mistake in my analagy that I used. I have read some of your post on trail use/closure and I think if I were frame the Amateur Radio thing within that framework you might understand it better, maybe not agree (and that is fine) but understand.
So lets look at it like this..
You are going out on a trail run that will go onto Az State Trust Land, or Sedona or Bulldog and a fellow shows up without whatever permit is req.
You mention to him, "Hey you need a permit to go with us, it is cheap and easy to get, why didn't you do it?" (kind of like the Ham lic)
His reply is "So what, these are public lands and I can use'em, I pay taxes" (like when folks want to use any radio on any freq).
Your reply might be " Yeah but the State needs to control access to limit trash and damage, also those fees go towards trail upkeep" (like how the FCC makes sure the cops have a clear channel and truckers aren't stepping on NASA comm)
So he says "What a waste of time and energy, you just want these trails to yourself and to not let others run them. What are you gonna do report me?"
(kind of like when folks get mad that hams police themselves)
Trying to be friendly you mention "Well no but if enough folks just do whatever they want then the Gov, or enviro groups have an excuse to close the trail to us" (like the fact that comercial interest would love more chunks of the radio spectrum and hams would be the ones who lost out)
So this little exchange could be about radios or trails as the ideas are the same...a group following the rules to protect a resource and enjoy it at the same time.
I know you can't stand trash on the trails (trash talk on the air)
I know you explain how stacking rocks is bad (Tx out of band)
I know you explain that a person should have the right equip to run a certain level trail (right radio and lic to Tx)
So I know you understand protecting a limited resource from waste, abuse, and having it taken away.
I really think if you have the same frame of mind about ham as you do about trail conservation then it might click...not enough to make you want to be an amateur operator but enough that you mind understand why things are like they are.
I do agree that there are lots of crabby ol' men in Ham Radio and as a newbie I have been roasted over the coals..that is 1 reason I am trying to help other new offroader hams just like we help other new offroaders.
Of course I haven't touched on the value of emerg comm during diaster, search and rescue, storm watch, long distance comm to home/help when out of cell range or lots of other uses.
This thread was about why cb folks should take a look at Ham radio, kind of like looking at a single axle conversion....maybe it is for you maybe not....but we can all agree to see both sides of it without making fun of the other camp.
Oh and on the seriousness thing...well that is just me
