I was at Donohoe Racing last week, talking about suspension and tires. They highly recommend the Nitto Terra Graplers and use them on their racing FJ that won the Baha 500 and came in second on the Baha 1000 (or maybe I have it backwards). Anyway, we were talking tire construction, etc. and I think it's less likely that it's the tire and more likely where you had it installed and balanced.
Remember that Nitto is new to the tire manufacture business. Toyo used to make their tires for them and now Nitto is making their own (in Georgia). Since you aren't matching tire conicity to the rim when the replacement market tires are installed, it will (almost) never be as good as the OE in that respect.
Tires are manufactured by assembling components made of rubber, fabric cord and steel wire that are cured together in a mold. Under intense heat and pressure during the curing process, the rubber reaches a near liquid state before vulcanization takes place finalizing the tire's exact size, structure and shape.
If a tire's internal components are misaligned as it cures, it is possible that unequal internal forces may cause the vehicle to pull to the side, even when it is steered straight ahead. When this occurs with a brand new tire it is typically due to conicity, a manufacturing glitch where a tire's tread has cured slightly cone shaped rather than in the desirable uniform cylinder shape.
OE tires are CAREFULLY matched to the rims they're mounted on based on conicity factors (note the red/blue dot on the OE tire - chalk marks across the tread in white or green). When you buy replacement market tires, you should look at the age of the tire (it's on the tire by week and year of manufacture, for example 0107 would be the first week of January 2007). If it's over a year old, don't buy it.
Likely it is the mounting and not the tire in the case of Nitto. There are a lot of other brands of tires out there for off-road applications that are just not very good. Tires vary based on the material used to construct them, the engineering of the tire itself and the care given the tire as it is stored and distributed before you ever see it.
Just my .02 cents worth on this.
