Three great choices.....bottom line you will be very pleased with any one of the three. My 2 cents =
Pro’s Vs Cons:
The Expedition One Trail Series Bumper (EX1-TS) does have a very large winch bay which I believe accepts a larger range of winches then the Demello Off Road Single Center Hoop Bumper (DO-SH) model will (however the DO-SH really fits all the good winches on the market).
The EX1-TS does not look as goofy with a roller fair lead where as the DO-SH bumper looks like the synthetic line fair lead was the intended set up.
DO-SH bumper has slightly better approach angle than the EX1-TS
Metal Tech Tube Bumper (MTTB) is most likely the strongest (due to the tube design) also the lightest of the three plus has a larger range of winch choices than the DO-SH.
Things to consider:
If you plan on changing out the rear bumper having a matching front is nice. I.e. think about the rear bumpers as well when evaluating the front bumpers.
Ask how there bumpers match up with existing after market skids out there.
Ask if you can mount a high lift jack via tube clamp mount to the bumper.
My experience with Expedition One:
Great experience dealing with EX1 and excellent after sale service. I honestly could not imagine a better bumper or better company to deal with. I have a 12,000 lb winch mounted on my EX1-TS and have double snatched it in some odd angles pulling out full sized trucks and have had no issues.
Obligatory shameless pic: