Youre partially correct. But in practice alternators are not designed to power every imaginable thing you ever could think to add to your truck. You can add too much, then the battery picks up the slack. (snip)
Partially correct?
Nowhere did I suggest that the STOCK alternator could "power every imaginable thing you ever could think to add to your truck".
As far as the battery "picking up the slack", this is a bit of a risky situation. If you've got a poorly matched alternator-output-to-accessory-load situation, the battery CAN provide some supplementary power for short periods of time (like limited time idling), but this is an indication of a marginal electrical system. This is probably of no concern to a mall cruiser where the AAA man is just a phone call away, but assuming that you occasionally use your FJ as an off-road vehicle driven solo to isolated locations, I wouldn't want an electrical system that was constantly discharging the battery during extended idling, even if I had an isolated secondary battery.
Maybe I'm just old school, but I prefer robust design margins wherever possible.
Think of the charging system on a typical police-special Crown Vic, that can idle for 8 hours with the AC, PC, radios, headlights, and light bar all on simultaneously, with a single battery.
QUOTE]
As for the "every imaginable thing", it was an obvious over exaggeration due to your blanket statement:
"Technically, your battery shouldn't be powering ANY of this stuff, except for a very limited time when the engine is not running. Your "starting" battery is for starting the engine; once the engine is running, your alternator is the source of power for all these loads."
Which is only partially true. If the alternator is capable of supporintg, lets say, the truck and all OEM accessories and have capacity for, lets say, 30 additional amps and you have 100 amps of extra (non OEM) accessories youre trying to power, where do you think the extra 70 amps the alternator can't supply is going to come from ?
I see you didn't bother to read the thread did you? :|