It's better to break a plastic taillight than to bend the body panel and ruin the paint. They're nothing but damage multipliers, as are the OEM and aftermarket "brush guards".
These painted or bedliner coated black are much better. Amazon.com: EAG Chrome Taillight Lamp Cover Bezel Trim Kit Fit for 2007-2014 FJ Cruiser: Automotive
Putco used to make these. Your ride, your choice. Good Luck!
View attachment 1132187
View attachment 1132188