Are these OEM Toyota parts, or some low-budget "imported" copies?

Can you post a photo of BOTH handles side-by-side so we can see exactly what you are talking about?

 

Yeah aftermarket a-1auto

 

 

Remove the silver paint, the black you seek is underneath.

 

Thanks. To late. After a long search I found a site that sold me just one key hole cover for 11 bucks. It’s all good.