Au contraire, I believe it's just the opposite....
If you're a rock crawler, don't comment on the use of a roof top tent unless you have experience using one ......
Strong words.
I'm not sure if I'm considered a "rock crawler". I have crawled on rocks, I liked it, I don't crawl on them daily, but in spite of your demands, I'm pretty sure I can still comment.
I think anyone who wants to buy a RTT should. It's their money. No need to label everyone and judge who should and who should not purchase one.
If people find out they don't like it, no big hairy deal. Not a life changing investment.
For me, I laugh out loud when I see them on top of jeeps, trucks and suvs.
I'm not hating, just laughing. They bring me joy.
I'm sure in Africa, I would feel much differently about them.
I've owned just about every type of camping vehicle/tent/RV there is. Except for a RTT.
Choosing the perfect one is a real chore.
What works extremely well on one trip, isn't practical on the next.
The main thing is that we are getting out, enjoying nature with our friends and loved ones.
Happy camping,
MJ