I rented RTT to test it before I decide to buy and so far I wasn't convinced I should get one.
I rented Sheepie Yuna Medium (Dutch brand). I recorded video of setting it up and it took 4 minutes and 40 seconds. I was doing it first time ever. But after that, I had a bit of the fight with the ladder, to level the overhanging part of the tent. It took good 10 minutes to set it properly.
I'm rather average sized female, so opening the tent was hard for me.
Then I didn't use my car on second day of the trip, because I didn't want the hassle of packing the tent. Because of that I had to hike longer distance than I would like, as I had no other transport option.
When I got to packing the tent, it was bad too. First, I forgot to put the cover on top, second time I put it wrong and had to open and close the tent three times to make it right. A lot of hassle and again, quite heavy to put the tent up and down again. Also got wet and dirty from wet tent (moisture) and ladder. I think, I provided quite an entertainment for others on camp site. One guy stopped by later to comment on my efforts of putting the tent down.
Other things I didn't like:
- a lot of condensation inside, even though I opened windows for the night
-going up and down the ladder
-lower mpg. I topped up before renting a tent and after returning it, to compare.
-lack of any private space without annexe
Test was done in November on mild weekend in England. We don't have dangerous wild animals and don't do wild camping, so totally different from USA, AU or Africa.
I plan to rent hard shell RTT and see if it's any better.
So far, I think standard tent is better option for me. And on short trips when it's wet, sleeping in the car is ok. I have couple of tents and use them depending on the weather, destination and how long is my trip. Pop up tents can be setup really quickly with minimal hassle.